Alan said to Katherine, "I like the sound of that, what Kim just said: fuck toy. Are you my fuck toy?" He remembered Katherine had used that term before, both a few minutes earlier and when she had snuck into his room just after midnight the previous night. It sounded sexy, but he hoped that it didn't have any meaning beyond that.
"You know it!" she replied enthusiastically. Then she shifted to a whisper. "I live just to be fucked by you! Now I can tell you something. I wanted your thing deep inside me even before you started your medical treatment. I've secretly wanted it for years, ever since I saw you naked and aroused in the shower one day. That's why I never really fooled around with any guy, and why I appeared so prudish. Well, that, and trying to be like Mom."
He was really shocked. "But you never let on. No flirting or anything."
"I know! It was my secret shame. I don't think I ever would have acted on it if it weren't for what's happened these past few weeks. I figured you were - and still are - such a good-hearted, morally upstanding guy that you'd hate me if I expressed any sexual feelings towards you. And I was chicken. God, I was unhappy sexually and didn't really understand why. I could barely even admit my feelings to myself. But now that's all over, thank God, 'cos I have you."
Alan was very surprised by all that. He'd never had the slightest clue she felt that way. He decided he'd absorb all this information later; right now he'd just get back to fucking.
Seeing him start to reposition himself, she eagerly began to do the same. "Let's fuck some more!"
"Okay," he said at first, but then an important consideration came to him. "Hold on, Sis. I have some bad news. Do you realize we forgot to use a condom?"
"Really? You're right. Oh well. You could be a father." She seemed completely unfazed by that possibility, and maybe even a bit gleeful about it. In fact, she now appeared even more interested in getting his erection back inside her before he could find a condom. She held it and drew it closer to her cum-smeared cunt.
"Wait a sec! Just hold on! Is that all you're going to say: ho hum, you could be a father? We're talking pregnancy here!"
"I know, and it gets me hot! Big Brother, I don't think you understand the whole fuck-toy concept here. Fuck toys don't complain, they don't make demands, they just get fucked. My pussy is now yours to use as you please, and so is my womb. The way I figure, if you get me pregnant then we'll be bonded together in a new and powerful way, and you'll just fuck me and love me even more than you already do."
Alan looked stricken. He thought she was taking the "fuck toy" idea too far. But even more concerning was her sounding serious about wanting to get pregnant.
Katherine saw his face and quickly changed her tune. "Awww, don't be like that. I know you're not ready for kids yet, and I'm even younger than you. That's why I'm on the pill already."
"You are?!"
"Yep! All of us cheerleaders are; Heather made us do it to stop our periods so it wouldn't interfere with our cheerleading. We take an active pill every day and skip the week of dummy pills that normally bring on a period. Aunt Suzy got the pills for me and Amy; she says that she's used the same method herself to stop her periods."
She continued, "Unfortunately, I might not have been taking them for long enough just yet to be really safe; that takes at least a month. But I am wearing a diaphragm as well. AND I've got a day-after pill, just in case everything else fails. We're totally covered."
"Phew! You scared me there. But don't you think a condom would be good just to be that much safer?"
"Nope. I took all these precautions 'cos I wanted to feel you bareback the first time and every time. That's how you fuck a fuck toy: bareback. Why should you care if you're knocking her up? All that matters is that she has a cunt and you're going to use it as you like to get your pleasure."
"Whoa, Sis, that's not how I look at it at all. A guy has to respect the girl's feelings and ask her if-"
She interrupted as she climbed on top of him, "Hey! I've been fantasizing about being a fuck toy for a long time now. Can't you just humor me and do the touchy-feely sensitive-guy thing another day? I guarantee you won't knock me up, but we can pretend otherwise. That's the fun of it!"
By the time Alan got a chance to reply, "Okay," she had already slid down over his pole and was balls-deep.
He joked, "I guess that's a 'No' to using a condom, then."
"Correct!" she said as she raised herself up and re-impaled herself. "Ahhh! In fact," - she raised herself up again, - "it's pretty much a rule that fuck toys always get fucked" - she lowered back down - "bareback!"
Alan thought with amusement, For all this supposed 'fuck toy' talk, in fact she's the same feisty and demanding Sis as ever. But that's just how I love her. Though I've got to admit that I could get into the 'sister as fuck toy' fantasy myself! Big time.
After raising herself up and re-impaling herself more times than they could easily count, she shouted, "Fill me up! Let's not leave the little spermies in there all lonely. Give them some new friends!"
He commented, "Wow, you are one sexy woman. Dangerously horny, too!"
"Mmmm. Big, Sexy, Sweaty Brother, this time, let's take our time." She clenched her vaginal muscles tightly while wiggling her bottom. The feeling of fullness while she sat on top of her brother with his dick buried so far inside her nearly overwhelmed her, it felt so great.
He was happy with that idea.
They proceeded much more slowly, like they were fucking in slow motion. He gradually pushed his prick deeper and deeper, up to the very hilt, and then pulled back just as slowly until all but the tip of his cock was out of her cunt. Then he did it again. And again.
He watched with awe as his sister's tits began to bounce slowly with each thrust of his dick. He thought, I guess this is the difference between fucking and making love. I've heard a lot about it, and now I know what they mean. This is even better than just plain fucking, because it feels like the love between us is growing stronger and stronger!
"God, I can hardly wait until you cum inside me again!" she sighed with a shudder. "Fill me up with your seed until it overflows and spills everywhere!"
"I would say what you just said really turned me on," he responded between labored breaths, "But there's no way I can be any more turned on than I am already... It's funny, 'cos I never really thought about you in that way. You know, before this all started."
"Awww, I'm hurt," she pouted.
He clarified, "Sis, I totally lusted after you, don't get me wrong. You're so beautiful! But it was forbidden, so I fought those feelings as hard as I could. Masturbating to a mental image of you made me feel really guilty. But the main thing was, I figured you'd think I was a freak and hate me for it."
"You were so wrong!"
"I know! Jesus. Just think about all the wasted nights with our bedrooms just across the hall from each other, and no fucking going on. What a tragic waste! Now help make up for lost time."
She sighed sadly. "Don't remind me! I feel the exact same way. It's like a physical pain to think about all the opportunities we missed, all the lost time! You're just gonna have to fuck me that much more to make up for it!"
She rose up just the tiniest bit to give him more room to thrust deeply into her tight, cum-soaked cunt.
He thrust up at her relentlessly, ever so slowly increasing his pace.
As they reached a frenzied climax, he pulled her down to him and rolled over, so that he ended up lying on top of her. They kissed and ran their hands everywhere. There wasn't as much screaming now since they were too busy kissing. The two siblings basked in the warm glow of their love-making.
Although the slow pace felt just as wonderful to each of them as their faster pace had, he abruptly pulled out of her altogether.
She suddenly felt empty inside, like someone had taken a part of her body away from her. She hated that feeling. "What are you doing?!" she yelled incredulously. "Why did you stop? Fuck me more! Harder! Fuck me now!"
From the next room they heard Kim yell, "Yeah, what's the big deal? Give her what I need! I mean, what she needs!"
"Both of you, slow down!" he said, while tapping the head of his cock on his sister's swollen, ember-hot clit.
That made Katherine arch her back in response, trying to impale herself again on his stiffness.
He said, "In these few weeks of my limited sexual experience, I learned that delayed gratification is twice as sweet. Let's hold off as long as we can, taking our time. That way, we can have fun for hours. Where'd those condoms go? Give me a sec to put one on."
"Don't you dare! Make me a mommy!"
He confirmed, "Fuck toy fantasy, right?"
"Right."
"Good."
While she was still relatively calm from resting, she explained, "You gotta understand, Brother. With a fuck toy, there's no breaking up, ever. There's no cheating, no running off with some hunky lifeguard. There's no, 'Sorry, I've got a headache.' Well, not unless I was like violently vomiting or something. Basically, my cunt belongs to you for as long as you want it."
He began to pound his sister with renewed vigor. He was getting off on her ideas. But he asked, "You mean, you're not going to still date other guys? I assumed that you would."
She giggled, "I know what you're thinking, Bro! You're thinking, 'If she's gonna be exclusive with me, then it's expected that I'm gonna be exclusive with her.' Nope! Fuck toys don't complain about sharing. In fact, I think it's only polite if you give Kim a good pumping before you go."
"Really?!"
"Really!" In fact, she burned with jealousy, but she figured there was no way she could have him exclusively, not given all the things happening with Susan, Suzanne, and even Amy lately. In fact, to compete with Susan and Suzanne in particular, she figured she had to try to be as open about sharing as possible. Besides, she wasn't totally opposed to the idea. Even as her jealousy burned inside, she found the idea of Alan fucking other girls strangely exciting and arousing.
They were getting too worked up with their piston-like movements to talk much more about it, but he decided, Weird! Too friggin' bizarre! The thing is, I'm really warming to the whole fuck toy idea. I guess she wants to shock me, to shake up my opinion of her so I'll have no doubt that she's not the clone of our prudish mom that she appeared to be. And thank God she's okay with sharing. That saves me from some big, big problems!
"Last time was good," she said with growing arousal, "but give me all you've got this time!"
"Hey, I gave you all I had last time," he chuckled.
"Give me more! Even more! Fuck me! Go deep! Break me in two! Fuuuuuccckkk meeeeeeeeee!"
He obeyed her gladly. He literally bounced his hips up and down on her body, making his shaft slide completely in and out of her. He would rise up so that his cock was completely exposed to the air, then he would pile-drive his pole right back into her upturned cunt as far as he could go.
They screamed and squirmed and climaxed. Sweat flew everywhere as Alan's cum shot off deep inside. He realized it was a very satisfying feeling to fill a vagina. He'd already realized that he really got off on the idea of "marking" his women with facials and pearl necklaces, but he instantly decided there was no more definitive way to claim a woman than by shooting off deep in her cunt.
"Mmmm! That was soooooo gooood!" Katherine said in a lazy and relaxed tone.
"Mmmm..." he happily agreed.
As they lay back and rested again, Kim poked her head into the room. "Thumbs up on round two, y'all," she said as she flashed them the thumbs-up sign.
They all laughed.
And then Kim said, "That gives me an idea," and stuck her thumb into her slit.
Everyone laughed again.
Katherine said, "Good idea," and stuck Alan's thumb into hers.
As Kim walked out of the room, she said, "Do either of you want anything this time?"
Katherine yelled back, "I'll take my brother's wide, thick, meaty cock deep in my cunt, please! And I'm thirsty, too. But don't get me a drink; I know just where to get all the tangy sweet cum I could ever need! At least until they put it on the cafeteria menu." She switched positions and began to suck his penis back to life.
Eventually she had success, so she kept sucking it with even more enthusiasm.
But after some minutes, Alan said, "Hey! You know, you can do that anytime at home. Let's fuck some more."
"But I want to taste you this time."
"In that case, when I'm ready to shoot, you can suck me off."
"That's a hard sell, Mister," she giggled.
He sat up.
She sat up on all fours and raised her ass to him. "This time, let's try doggy-style! So many things I've been reading about that I can finally try out for real."
He thrust his hips forward at the same time that she thrust backward.
He was amazed at the difference between this and fucking a relatively motionless body. He decided right away that doggy-style was great.
They worked in perfect rhythm. Not only did her vaginal muscles clench each time she thrust back at him, but his own posture made it possible to thrust with less exertion, which meant that he could keep going with a steady rhythm even longer.
Then there was the feel of her ass as it pushed back against his hips. It was so soft, smooth, and warm that he couldn't help but grab hold of her by both hips and luxuriate in the feeling of her skin even as he watched his rod disappear and reappear. Each time he pulled out of his sister's moist pussy, her inner lips seemed to drag along his shaft, like they were still joined even when he pulled out.
He decided, Doggy-style is definitely most excellent. I could do this for days! But the best thing of all is that I think I'm reaching a lot deeper this way.
Sure enough, he kept his promise to let her swallow his load even though he would have enjoyed filling her with his cum again. When he pulled out after many minutes of doggy-style fucking, she was right there to drink up his spurting ropes.
When they were done, he pointed out, "You know, I'm fairly amazed that you didn't mind that my dick was covered with your own pussy juices."
"Brother, you're so cute but so dumb. I'm your fuck toy now. I'll try anything, just so long as it doesn't involve another guy or guys. That's where I draw my line."
"As if I'd ever want to share you. Ha! I can tell you now that ain't ever gonna happen."
/////////////////////////////
Please consider Donating however much you can to support me.
Every Little Donation motivates me to do better works.
-----------------------------
https://ko-fi.com/snake_empress
/////////////////////////////
